| Book
review by Joel M. Kauffman,
Ph. D.
Determined to have non-biochemists follow the scientific
evidence for the effect of diet, supplements, and drugs on
health, the husband and wife team of Fred and Alice Ottoboni
has provided informative diagrams of metabolic pathways on
digestion and beyond, along with clear descriptions in their
book "The
Modern Nutritional Diseases: Heart Disease, Stroke, Type 2
Diabetes, Obesity, Cancer, and How to Prevent Them."
And all of this is done without using a single chemical structure--quite
a shock to an organic chemist such as myself, but certainly
a welcome feature to most lay readers.
The Ottobonis have shown how common supplements and drugs
influence these metabolic pathways, and they expose the biggest
fraud in the history of medicine and diet without restraint.
I am referring of course to the fraud that claims that dietary
fat is dangerous and causes heart disease.
Despite the contrarian viewpoint of the book, most of their
sources and references are from mainstream biochemistry texts
and medical journals. Yet their interpretation of the science
differs from the desperate defense of the deceptive dictatorial
directives of the dons of diet dogma so much that the Ottobonis
call their recommendations "alternative nutrition."
This is not to say that their tone is anything but sweet
and reasonable, and it is gratifying to see their contempt
for the low-fat fools emerge just a little here and there.
The authors' advice, which is possibly the most experimentally
valid advice ever given on healthful behaviors, diet, supplements
and drugs is given with solid citations and great clarity.
Dozens of their paragraphs are gems of clear, truthful and
practical correlations, which should be prize quotations verbatim
for many years to come. For example, here are just a few of
their accurate observations, which are presented with ample
evidence:
- Acetaminophen is not innocuous
- Fats made from the 12-carbon lauric acid are very beneficial
- Children on low-fat diets can be harmed seriously
- Certain vitamins and supplements (but relatively few
herbs) can be very beneficial
- A vegetarian diet is not a healthy one
- Cholesterol-lowering drugs are dangerous
- A good cholesterol supply in the human body is a vital
necessity
Certainly, there is broad agreement with the principles in
Dr. Mercola’s "The No-Grain
Diet" (which I have not yet read, but am familiar
with the basic principles of it, being a regular reader of
his newsletter).
The biochemical path from high glycemic index carbohydrates
to high insulin to undesirable eicosanoids (prostaglandins,
etc.) is presented in the clearest manner I have yet seen.
For those who cannot accept experimental evidence without
a plausible theory, the Ottobonis provide both.
The Ottobonis correctly expose the National Cholesterol Education
Program Guidelines on diet as an attempt by those with ulterior
motives to use the U.S. government umbrella of the National
Heart, Lung and Blood Institute of the National Institutes
of Health to make it appear that the guidelines have government
sanction, and that the process of generating them was the
open and complete process we have a right to expect, which
would have included public hearings and publication in the
Federal Register.
Flaws in dietary studies connecting consumption of saturated
fats with the chronic Western diseases are explained. Many
examples of better studies are provided, and the contradiction
with the Unified Dietary Guidelines of The American Heart
Association and other groups still in the Dark Ages regarding
glycemic index are exposed fearlessly.
Despite the fact that the book is excellent, I doubt that
a book could be possibly written that I would be in 100 percent,
complete agreement with. Perhaps the Ottobonis’ homage
to Barry Sears, author of "Into The Zone," should
have been qualified. In addition, the first edition of the
book had less-than-perfect proofreading and some minor errors
in chemistry, both of which were eliminated in the second
printing in February 2003. However, these minor complaints
did not alter the validity of the conclusions and advice in
this marvelous book.
The bottom line is that "The
Modern Nutritional Diseases" is an essential part
of any health library, and it gets a perfect score of five
out of five stars.
For
additional accurate diet information see www.THINCS.org.
Joel
M. Kauffman, PhD. is professor of chemistry emeritus, University
of the Sciences in Philadelphia (e-mail: kauffman37@yahoo.com)
Related Articles:
High-Grain Diet
May Increase Risk of Cardiovascular Disease
How to Properly
Lower Your Triglycerides
Low-Fat Diets
Cause Injuries in Runners
Are Low-Fat Diets
Safe or Beneficial For Kids?
Learn the Dangers
of Modern Low-Fat Diets in This Exclusive Interview With
the Author of Acclaimed Cookbook, "Nourishing Traditions"
Scientist Questions
Benefits of Low Fat Diets
|