FREE Subscription
The World’s Most Popular Natural Health Newsletter   
 
 
POSTED BY
August 18 2001
1,498 Views

BROWSE BY CATEGORY

Should You Take Antioxidants With Zocor?

 

Supplementing the diet with antioxidant vitamins and minerals appears to blunt the beneficial effects of certain cholesterol-lowering drugs.

Their findings suggest that patients with coronary artery disease who are taking Zocor and niacin should steer clear of supplements containing vitamins E and C, beta-carotene or selenium.

Patients who took a "cocktail" of these four antioxidants along with Zocor and niacin had smaller increases in HDL ("good") cholesterol levels over a 1-year period, compared with patients who took the medications alone, the investigators found. Zocor and niacin have been shown to reduce total cholesterol and LDL ("bad") cholesterol while boosting levels of HDL, which helps cut the risk of heart disease.

The findings, however, do not suggest that patients avoid fruits and vegetables, which are naturally rich in antioxidants and contain a number of other compounds that may protect against heart disease.

The findings were based on antioxidant supplements and not foods that are naturally rich in antioxidants.

After one year, patients on Zocor and niacin alone saw their HDL increase by an average of 25%, while HDL levels rose by an average of 18% among patients on the medications plus antioxidants.

What's more, the HDL component responsible for most of its protective effects increased by an average of 42% with medication, but remained unchanged among patients who added the antioxidant cocktail.

Arteriosclerosis, Thrombosis, and Vascular Biology August 2001;21:1253, 1319-1325



Dr. Mercola Dr. Mercola's Comments:

It would appear that you can't have your cake and eat it too. If you want to take the easy way out and take a pill like Zocor, or any of the other statin drugs for that matter, it appears that taking antioxidants may blunt the benefit of these drugs.

However, in light of Baycol being taken off the market this week do you think it is wise to take these drugs?

My suggestion is to aggressively implement the eating plan, as when that is combined with an exercise program, it seems to work in normalizing cholesterol in over 95% of people without the use of drugs or supplements.

Now most traditionally based physicians will use the above to justify not taking antioxidants.

Well, they certainly could do that, but they are misinterpreting this study as this study is asking the question: Are antioxidants blunting some of the pharmacological effects for those with low HDL levels taking a Statin drug along with niacin? It is important to note that the people in the study did not have elevated total cholesterol levels, with their average being less than 200.

The study did not ask the question are antioxidants beneficial for anyone with heart disease.

That question has been asked in previous study in NEJM (Volume 328:1450-1456 May 20, 1993) and the answer appears to be an overwhelming YES.

However, in light of the other article on antioxidants in this week's newsletter you may want to reconsider your decision to take antioxidants.

Clearly, without any question or expert disagreeing, the best form of antioxidant supplementation will be to receive them from whole foods.

This is why I strongly recommend the use of vegetable juicing.

Related Articles:

Vitamin E Reduces Heart Disease

Vitamin E May Reduce Heart Disease in Diabetics

Vitamin E-Who Are You Going to Believe?

Antioxidants The Good, The Bad and the Evil

Did you find this article interesting?  Interesting Not Useful
Community Comments ( 0 )
Comment on this Article

 
Truste
 
Mercola